[ad_1]
An Ashburton man denied 4 intercourse prices with an underage lady when he appeared earlier than Decide Dominic Dravitzki within the Ashburton District court docket on Monday.
Organiser Iele Laupa’E, 37, faces three prices of sexual violation of a woman underneath 12 and certainly one of illegal sexual connection.
The offences have been allegedly dedicated between 2019 and 2021.
Lele Laupa’E pleaded not responsible and elected to have a judge-alone trial. He’ll seem once more on March 18.
Decide Dravitzki mentioned there have been no grounds for ongoing identify suppression for Iele Laupa’E besides to guard the complainant. After checking that her caregiver was not not against publication, Decide Dravitzki dominated that interim identify suppression wouldn’t proceed.
Assault, wounding denied
Rueben Mcgregor Sivaivai, 30, pleaded not responsible to a cost of wounding one man and assaulting second man on November 30 final 12 months.
Lawyer Cory Shaw mentioned Sivaivai elected to have a judge-alone trial.
He’ll seem once more on March 18.
Neighborhood detention sentence
A 66-year-old man was given a group detention sentence for driving whereas disqualified twice in a single month.
Gary David Snelling admitted driving whereas disqualified on November 7 and 23 final 12 months.
He’d been disqualified for 3 months on September 19 as a part of a sentence for a number of petrol drive-off thefts.
Lawyer Jennifer North utilized for a discharge with out conviction. She mentioned Snelling didn’t count on a disqualification when he was sentenced for the petrol thefts.
North mentioned Snelling was the caregiver for his companion, who suffered from a persistent medical situation.
Snelling admitted to the choose that he was conscious of the disqualification on the second date in November.
“There was an important medical appointment – and I actually didn’t know what else to do,” Snelling mentioned.
Decide Dravitzki mentioned this was Snelling’s eighth and ninth conviction for driving whereas disqualified – though his final conviction was virtually precisely 9 years in the past.
He sentenced Snelling to 4 months’ group detention with a 7pm to 7am curfew and didn’t impose an extra disqualification.
Drink driving admitted
Monica Louise Rangiahuia, 39, pleaded responsible to a cost of drink driving. She blew 551 micrograms of alcohol per litre of breath when stopped by police on the Nice Level Freeway on January 1.
She’s going to seem once more on April 8.
Final likelihood
A girl was given one final likelihood to get her restricted licence earlier than being sentenced.
Natasha Christine Ranson, 32, appeared on a cost of driving whereas her licence was suspended on Chalmers Avenue on April 11, 2023, and a cost of careless driving on East Road on July 18 final 12 months.
Responsibility lawyer Paul Norcross mentioned he had hoped to use for a community-based sentence fairly than an extra disqualification. Nonetheless, Ranson was not allowed to take a seat her restricted check as a result of her licence was suspended attributable to demerit factors.
Her case was remanded to Could 20 to permit her to get her licence.
Costs denied
Seamus Anthony Lucas was remanded in custody after denying 4 prices.
The police allege the 42-year-old had methamphetamine, a bong for the usage of methamphetamine, an offensive weapon and devices for housebreaking in his possession on January 13.
Lucas will seem once more on March 18 when he’ll elected whether or not to have a jury or judge-alone trial.
Household violence admitted
Pauline Michelle Michie, 33, pleaded responsible to a cost of strangulation and a cost of assault on an individual with whom she had a household relationship on January 15.
She was remanded to permit for restorative justice and pre-sentence and can seem in court docket once more on April 8.
Software denied
Decide Dravitzki denied an utility to have a sentence cancelled.
Riley Lynton Molloy, 20, utilized to cancel his group detention and supervision sentence so he might head to Australia for work.
Molloy was sentenced to 4 months’ group detention and 9 months’ supervision on a raft of driving prices on December 11, 2023.
“One of many functions of sentencing is to carry you to account and to discourage others. That is reasonably critical offending – it’s essential full the penal facet of the sentence.”
Decide Dravitzki denied Molloy’s utility to cancel his group detention however did cancel his supervision sentence to permit him to go to Australia for work as quickly as his group detention was full.
Responsible plea
Allenton lady Dwana Timutimu, 31, admitted driving whereas disqualified on Farm Highway on November 22 final 12 months.
Lawyer Gretchen Hart requested the choose to withhold conviction to permit for an utility for a community-based sentence as an alternative of an extra disqualification.
Timutimu will seem once more on March 18.
Authorized prices declined
An utility for $5338 in authorized prices was declined after a choose discovered the police acted in good religion.
Mark Gintaras Seale, 25, was charged with careless driving inflicting damage in June 2022. Nonetheless, his case was dismissed in August final 12 months after Decide Dravitzki dominated his defence was prejudiced after police took 18 weeks to tell Seale he was topic to an investigation.
Seale’s lawyer Todd Nicholls utilized for an award of prices for the time he spent getting ready for Seale’s defence after a degree, he argued, that police had been suggested of alleged points with their investigation and elected to proceed.
Decide Dravitzki mentioned Seale had been driving a lightweight truck towing a heavy grain switch trailer, when he didn’t cease at an intersection with State Freeway One.
Seale informed police that his car had been pushed into the intersection by the trailer and suspected a problem with the brakes on both his car or the trailer he was towing.
“He heard nothing extra for 18 weeks very shortly earlier than he was formally charged… That delay misplaced Seale the chance to undertake his personal unbiased testing of the autos concerned which was prejudicial to him. I dismissed the cost accordingly,” Dravitzki mentioned.
The choose mentioned the police had investigated the brakes and located nothing fallacious. It was that investigation that induced the delay in prices.
Whereas the delay in advising Seale he was underneath investigation “was actual potential prejudice for Seale, the remainder of the prosecution proceeded in a cautious and orderly method”, the choose mentioned.
He discovered there have been no simply and cheap grounds to award prices.
Neighborhood work commuted
Decide Dravitzki permitted an utility to commute a group work sentence to a superb.
Hinds man Simonia Paul John, 41, was sentenced on a cost of possessing heroin and shopping for amphetamine within the Christchurch District Court docket in January. He requested to commute the group work a part of his sentence to a superb.
Responsibility lawyer Paul Bradford mentioned group work in Ashburton was solely out there on Saturdays and John needed to work on Saturdays and stood to lose his job.
Decide Dravitzki transformed the group work to a $2500 superb.
Penalties unavoidable
A person was informed he couldn’t keep away from the results of demerit factors from a dashing superb.
Toby Jack Roberts, 31, requested a court docket listening to to keep away from a driving suspension when he paid a $80 dashing superb and the demerit factors kicked in.
Responsibility lawyer Paul Norcross mentioned Roberts hoped to do group work as an alternative.
Nonetheless, Decide Dravitzki mentioned the demerit level regime operated independently from the courts and there’s no scope for him to take a special strategy.
“Demerits comply with dashing as evening follows day,” he mentioned.
Roberts’ authentic $80 dashing infringement was imposed as a superb.
Diversion on the desk
A Netherby man was provided an opportunity to finish diversion to keep away from a felony conviction.
Oliver Raymond Taylor, 20, admitted taking a car for his personal functions and three prices of theft for utilizing a Mobil gas to purchase gas.
Decide Dravitzki entered Taylor’s responsible pleas and withheld conviction.
“When you full the diversion issues efficiently, you gained’t be convicted,: the choose mentioned.
Taylor will seem once more on Could 20.
Cost denied
Rakaia man James Jay Mavor, 35, denied driving whereas disqualified on Elizabeth Avenue on November 14 final 12 months.
He’ll seem once more on March 18.
Warrants issued
Decide Dravitzki issued two arrest warrants for individuals who failed to look within the Ashburton District Court docket on Monday.
Mount Cook dinner man Jone Vakarewa Delaibatiki, 36, failed to look on a drink driving cost after blowing 684mcg when stopped by police on Archibald Road on November 23 final 12 months.
The choose was not glad that Dorie lady, Aimee Elizabeth Mcgregor, 37, had automobile bother that prevented her from attending court docket on a cost of acquiring $1050 by deception in Oamaru on July 15, 2023.
Sergeant Whyte mentioned Mcgregor had claimed to be unwell and unable to attend court docket the final time she was due in court docket.
The choose declined to excuse Mcgregor’s non-attendance and issued a warrant.
By Sharon Davis
[ad_2]
Source link
