Assessing 6 Claims by the G.O.P. in the Biden Impeachment Inquiry

As they seek for proof they’ll use to question President Biden, Home Republicans have repeatedly pointed to proof that they are saying undercuts his claims that he by no means had something to do with the international enterprise dealings of his son, Hunter Biden.

As vice chairman, for instance, Mr. Biden did briefly meet with a few of his son’s enterprise associates, although there isn’t a testimony that he had any substantive discussions with them or that he modified authorities coverage to learn any of Hunter Biden’s ventures.

Nonetheless, Republicans have continued to mine voluminous information associated to Hunter Biden, together with a trove of messages from a pc arduous drive, to attempt to make a case that Hunter Biden’s revenue from overseas was on the coronary heart of an influence-peddling operation that enriched the whole Biden household, together with his father.

Republicans have used quotes culled from textual content messages or emails so as to add a confessional high quality to their shows — proof, they are saying, that Hunter Biden was primarily admitting that he and his father had been engaged in political corruption.

However an examination of a few of the highest-profile examples cited by Republicans reveals that they’ve been taken out of context, or that Republicans have omitted key messages in e-mail or textual content chains that always forged the communications in a extra innocuous gentle.

‘Half my wage’

In a single instance, Republicans level to a 2019 textual content message Hunter Biden despatched to his daughter by which, they are saying, he confesses to sharing half of the tens of millions he acquired from abroad enterprise offers together with his father.

“I Hope you all can do what I did and pay for all the things for this whole household Fro 30 years,” he wrote within the typo-filled message. “It’s actually arduous. However don’t fear in contrast to Pop I gained’t make you give me half your wage.”

Moderately than referring to cash Hunter Biden acquired from the Ukrainian power firm Burisma or from a enterprise with a Chinese language associate, Hunter Biden was alluding to his monetary assist for his personal kids and his college days, when his father allowed him to maintain half the paycheck from part-time jobs however requested that he flip over the opposite half to assist pay for room and board, in line with a evaluation of Hunter Biden’s messages and interviews by The New York Instances.

‘10 p.c for the massive man’

The phrase “10 p.c for the massive man” is nearly ubiquitous in Republican circles, stemming from the accusation that Hunter Biden gave his father a ten p.c stake in his enterprise offers.

It originates from a 2017 e-mail despatched by James Gilliar, a enterprise affiliate of Hunter Biden’s, who proposed together with the “huge man” — presumably Joseph R. Biden Jr., the previous vice chairman — in a enterprise enterprise below the title Oneida Holdings.

“10 held by H for the massive man?” Mr. Gilliar wrote.

However he instructed The Wall Avenue Journal in 2020 that his suggestion by no means went anyplace. The previous vice chairman didn’t get entangled with their enterprise, and the proposed deal by no means produced any revenue for anybody to separate.

“I want to clear up any hypothesis that former Vice President Biden was concerned with the 2017 discussions about our potential enterprise construction,” Mr. Gilliar stated in 2020. “I’m unaware of any involvement at any time of the previous vice chairman. The exercise in query by no means delivered any undertaking income.”

In an interview with the F.B.I., Rob Walker, Hunter Biden’s former enterprise associate, described recommendations of getting Hunter’s father concerned with the enterprise as “wishful pondering.” He said he “definitely by no means was pondering at any time that the V.P. was part of something we had been doing.”

‘I can work with you father alone !!’

One other message Republicans have highlighted is a 2018 textual content despatched from James Biden, the president’s brother, to Hunter Biden, who on the time was within the throes of habit to alcohol and crack cocaine: “I can work with you father alone !! We as standard simply want a number of months of his assist for this to work.”

At a Home Oversight Committee listening to, Republican lawmakers implied this message was in reference to enterprise dealings, however one other textual content within the chain makes clear James Biden was referring to working with Joe Biden to get assist for Hunter Biden as he struggled to maintain up together with his payments, get sober and discover a place to dwell.

Issues of a financial institution investigator

Republicans have additionally drawn consideration to the issues of a financial institution investigator about Hunter Biden’s enterprise actions, which concerned securing tens of millions of {dollars} from a Chinese language agency in alternate for work the investigator flagged as doubtlessly nonexistent.

“The exercise on the account seems uncommon with no present enterprise objective,” the investigator wrote.

However Republicans omitted different emails within the chain that had been later launched by Democrats on the Oversight Committee. They present a strong debate contained in the financial institution in regards to the legitimacy of the enterprise exercise. One response described the exercise linked to Hunter Biden’s account as “affordable and in keeping with the enterprise profile.”

$240,000 to Joe Biden

Regardless of assertions that anyplace from 10 p.c to half of the cash from Hunter Biden’s enterprise offers went to his father, Republicans have failed up to now to point out any revenue for the present president.

They’ve documented three situations by which members of the family paid cash to Joe Biden — whereas he was not in workplace — however they’ve usually omitted the context that the exchanges had been mortgage repayments, not a lower of revenue.

Moderately than exhibiting Joe Biden was enriched by his household’s international enterprise dealings, the paperwork launched by Home Republicans to this point have confirmed the alternative.

After leaving the vice presidency, Joe Biden made greater than $15 million, principally via talking engagements and guide gross sales, a few of which went to assist his prolonged household.

Against this, Hunter Biden spent a lot of his cash on alcohol, medicine, prostitutes, fancy automobiles and different self-indulgent bills and didn’t pay his taxes on time, leading to his federal indictment this month on tax costs.

James Biden additionally discovered himself once in a while in want of a mortgage. In line with Home Republicans, at one level, James Biden had simply $46 in a private account.

Home Republicans have pointed to 2 funds — one for $200,000 and one other for $40,000 — James Biden made to Joe Biden whereas he was not in workplace. They’ve characterised the $40,000 examine as “laundered China cash.” However they didn’t be aware proof exhibiting Joe Biden had first loaned cash to his brother earlier than being repaid.

The Home Oversight Committee has additionally launched paperwork that confirmed that one among Hunter Biden’s companies, Owasco PC, made three funds of $1,380 to Joe Biden in 2018. However different paperwork point out the cash was to pay again his father for serving to to cowl the price of a Ford truck.

‘I’m sitting right here with my father’

One WhatsApp message that has acquired a lot consideration was offered by an I.R.S. investigator who testified earlier than Congress below whistle-blower protections. In it, Hunter Biden invoked his father, who was then out of workplace, whereas urgent a possible Chinese language enterprise associate in 2017 to maneuver forward with a proposed power deal.

“I’m sitting right here with my father and we want to know why the dedication has not been fulfilled,” the message states. On its face, the message appeared to recommend Joe Biden was in league together with his son pressuring for a cost to the household.

However Democrats have argued it’s extra seemingly an instance of Hunter Biden’s bluster than an correct assertion of Joe Biden’s involvement in a shakedown. A lawyer for Hunter Biden says he doesn’t keep in mind sending the message.

The president has denied he was current on the time.