AMD X3D CPU Versus: 5800X3D vs 5700X3D vs 5600X3D

At this time, we’re evaluating the three X3D chips accessible on the AM4 platform: the Ryzen 5 5600X3D, Ryzen 7 5700X3D, and Ryzen 7 5800X3D. Technically, most of you’ll solely have entry to the Ryzen 7 fashions, because the 5600X3D is a Micro Heart unique that may at the moment be acquired for $200, though it has been included in some extremely engaging combo offers previously.

Then now we have the Ryzen 7 5700X3D, accessible on the $250 MSRP and accessible worldwide, together with the 5800X3D at $300. Quite a few readers have requested that we evaluate them to see which mannequin affords one of the best worth, particularly for gaming, so that is what we’ll be doing on this function.

For these of you not focused on gaming, it is possible you do not want a 3D V-Cache processor and can be higher off contemplating the bottom fashions

As a aspect observe, for these of you not focused on gaming, it is possible you do not want a 3D V-Cache processor and can be higher off contemplating the bottom fashions. Nevertheless, for gaming, particularly in eventualities the place the CPU is the limiting issue, the X3D components are distinctive. Fashions such because the newly launched 5700X3D supply AM4 house owners a fast and simple improve path that may considerably enhance body charges.

In our testing, we’ll give attention to CPU-limited gaming as we purpose to guage CPU efficiency, not total system or GPU efficiency. This strategy is just not supposed to steer you to improve, however reasonably that can assist you decide whether or not your present CPU is hindering your gaming expertise. There are a number of strategies to find out this, for instance, by monitoring GPU load and observing whether or not body charges enhance as you decrease the decision.

The thought of CPU-limited testing is to indicate you the true efficiency variations between two merchandise. There is no profit in GPU-limiting the Ryzen 5 3600 and Ryzen 7 5700X with a GeForce RTX 3060; if the load is 100% on the GPU, then clearly each CPUs will ship an identical efficiency.

This strategy utterly hides the truth that, when CPU-limited, the 5700X3D is 50% quicker than the Ryzen 5 3600. This does not essentially imply the 5700X3D affords higher worth than the 3600, but it surely lets you precisely assess the worth every product supplies, figuring out the actual efficiency variations. We wrote an in depth article on this subject when you’re focused on studying extra.

For now, let’s dive into the benchmarks to see how these CPUs evaluate…

Benchmarks

First up, now we have Baldur’s Gate 3, the place all three AM4 X3D processors delivered related efficiency at round 130 fps. Regardless of having two fewer cores, the 5600X3D matched the efficiency of the 8-core fashions, with its increased core clocks serving to it maintain tempo with the 5700X3D.

In comparison with the non-3D V-Cache fashions, we noticed a 25-30% efficiency uplift, with the 5600X3D providing probably the most vital acquire over its normal variant. Moreover, for these utilizing a processor just like the Ryzen 5 3600, the 3D V-Cache fashions on the AM4 platform present over a 60% efficiency uplift on this title.

Subsequent, we examined Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty, a title that’s considerably extra CPU intensive. Whereas it does not totally make the most of the 6-core 5600X3D, the 8-core fashions confirmed some efficiency advantages. As an illustration, the 5700X3D was 3% quicker than the 5600X3D, whereas the 5800X3D was 7% quicker.

This time, the X3D fashions confirmed a 22-26% efficiency enchancment over the usual variants. The 5600X3D additionally was 56% quicker than the Ryzen 5 3600, highlighting a major improve alternative for these nonetheless utilizing the older third technology Ryzen 5 mannequin.

Hogwarts Legacy is extremely CPU restricted, primarily as a result of poor optimization, which suggests the X3D fashions and the 8-core processors should not utilized as successfully as doable. The 5600X3D, for instance, was barely quicker than the 5700X3D as a result of it operates at the next clock velocity, indicating that though efficiency is considerably CPU restricted when utilizing the 5700X3D, the additional cores aren’t being leveraged.

In Star Wars Jedi: Survivor, the pattern continues with the 5600X3D matching the efficiency of the 5700X3D and 5800X3D, so all three fashions delivered comparable efficiency. Nevertheless, the 5600X3D lagged behind the 5700X3D by way of 1% lows, illustrating how growing processing effectivity with a bigger L3 cache can compensate for an absence of cores.

When in comparison with the usual fashions, the X3D chips are providing between 23-29% higher efficiency.

ACC is one other sport typically restricted by CPU efficiency, however not as a result of it makes use of excessive core rely CPUs. Like many trendy video games, it relies upon extra on the ‘main thread’. In consequence, the 5600X3D performs very effectively and matches the 5800X3D, making it 6% quicker than the 5700X3D, just because it operates at the next clock velocity.

The sport can also be delicate to cache dimension, ensuing within the 3D V-Cache fashions being about 40% quicker. Moreover, there’s an virtually 80% efficiency uplift when upgrading from the Ryzen 5 3600 to the 5600X3D.

In Spider-Man Remastered, the title can profit from further cores, relying on the bottom CPU efficiency. With Zen 3, we see a modest 4% uplift for the 5800X in comparison with the 5600X, after which a 7% enhance from the 5600X3D to the 5800X3D. Probably the most vital positive factors come from an elevated L3 cache capability, with the X3D chips providing as much as 23% extra efficiency.

The ends in A Plague Story: Requiem are noteworthy because the 5700X3D struggles to outperform the usual 5700X, suggesting that clock velocity is a main limitation right here. Nevertheless, the 5600X3D is 15% quicker than its non-3D variant, whereas the 5800X3D is 12% quicker than the 5800X. This additionally signifies that, as a result of its increased working frequency, the 5600X3D was barely quicker than the 5700X3D on this title.

In Murderer’s Creed Mirage, the title favors the 5800X3D over the 5600X3D, giving the 8-core mannequin a 12% efficiency benefit, although 1% lows have been comparable. The 5700X3D additionally managed to outperform the higher-clocked 5600X3D, however solely by a 4% margin.

When in comparison with the bottom fashions, the X3D variants have been typically about 30% quicker, marking a major enchancment. The 5600X3D was additionally 56% quicker than the Ryzen 5 3600.

Efficiency in Watch Canine: Legion is persistently excessive throughout the Zen 3 components, with a mean of round 155 fps for an X3D mannequin in comparison with 116 fps for the standard mannequin. This represents simply over a 30% efficiency increase with the 3D V-Cache components.

The 5600X3D was additionally 68% quicker than the Ryzen 5 3600 and barely outpaced the newer Ryzen 5 7600X.

Lastly, we examined Hitman 3 and, as noticed beforehand, core rely doesn’t appear to considerably impression fps efficiency for these Zen 3 processors; cache dimension and clock velocity play extra essential roles. As an illustration, the 5600X3D matched the efficiency of the 5800X3D virtually precisely, making it 17% quicker than the usual 5800X and 30% quicker when evaluating 1% lows.

12 Sport Common

This is the typical efficiency throughout 12 video games, and as anticipated primarily based on our observations, the 5600X3D matches the efficiency of each the 5700X3D and 5800X3D. Technically, it is 2% quicker on common than the 5700X3D and three% slower than the 5800X3D, indicating a comparable degree of efficiency.

For these nonetheless utilizing a processor just like the Ryzen 5 3600, the newly launched 5700X3D will supply round 50% extra gaming efficiency when CPU restricted, which is kind of exceptional for $250. It is also price noting that the 5700X3D, alongside the 5600X3D and 5800X3D, carried out on par with the Ryzen 5 7600X. Though the newer AM5 processor is perhaps barely cheaper, the related reminiscence and motherboard prices will likely be increased.

Subsequently, when you’re on the lookout for a major improve from the AM4 X3D chips to AM5, you would wish to contemplate the far more costly 7800X3D, which was, on common, 31% quicker than the 5800X3D.

What We Discovered

The Ryzen 5 5600X3D is fairly arduous to beat at $200 by way of worth – it principally matches or edges out the 5700X3D in all of our gaming checks. The 5700X3D prices ~25% extra and it got here nowhere close to delivering that form of efficiency acquire. The issue is that as a Micro Heart unique, most of you will not have entry to this half, so the truth that it is fairly nice worth is simply annoying.

You do get 33% extra cores with the 5700X3D for simply $50 extra although, with a 25% value enhance within the course of, and whereas that does not show helpful within the video games we examined, this mannequin will certainly age higher. In any case, it is the most cost effective X3D processor most of you should have entry to and at $250 it is fairly nice.

You are additionally getting Ryzen 5 7600X-like efficiency, with out having to spend huge cash on an AM5 motherboard and DDR5 reminiscence.

The 5800X3D is actually the identical CPU however with a clock velocity benefit. It prices 20% extra and affords simply 5% extra efficiency on common, so naturally most of you’re higher off shopping for the 5700X3D.

These X3D CPUs are a superb possibility for these working a Zen 3 or older CPU as we noticed on common a 52% enhance over the Ryzen 5 3600, and that is a major efficiency enhance (in CPU restricted eventualities) that is effectively well worth the $250 funding for AM4 house owners. You are additionally getting Ryzen 5 7600X-like efficiency, with out having to spend huge cash on an AM5 motherboard and DDR5 reminiscence.

Purchasing Shortcuts: